in a 2D Electron Gas
Adam C. Durst, Subir Sachdev, N. Read, and S. M. Girvin
Department of Physics, Yale University, P.O. Box 208120, New Haven, CT 06520-8120
(Dated: January 29, 2003)
Recent measurements of a 2D electron gas subjected to microwave radiation reveal a magnetoresis-
tance with an oscillatory dependence on the ratio of radiation frequency to cyclotron frequency. We
perform a diagrammatic calculation and nd radiation-induced resistivity oscillations with the cor-
rect period and phase. Results are explained via a simple picture of current induced by photo-excited
disorder-scattered electrons. The oscillations increase with radiation intensity, easily exceeding the
dark resistivity and resulting in negative-resistivity minima. At high intensity, we identify additional
features, likely due to multi-photon processes, which have yet to be observed experimentally.
PACS numbers: 73.40.-c, 78.67.-n, 73.43.-f
The electrical transport properties of a 2D electron
gas (2DEG) in a perpendicular magnetic eld have been
studied extensively over the past two decades in con-
nection with the quantum Hall eects.
However, re-
cent experiments, in which such systems are subjected to
electromagnetic radiation, reveal a surprising new phe-
nomenon. The initial experiments of Zudov et al. [1],
as well as more detailed subsequent studies conducted
by Mani et al. [2] and Zudov et al. [3], show that a
peculiar oscillation of the longitudinal resistance is in-
duced by the presence of microwave radiation in systems
at high lling factor. Unlike the familiar Shubnikov-de
Haas (SdH) oscillations which are controlled by the ratio
of the chemical potential, , to the cyclotron frequency,

c
, these radiation-induced oscillations are controlled by
the ratio of the radiation frequency, , to the cyclotron
frequency. According to Ref. 2, the minimum resistance
values are obtained near /
c
= integer + 1/4. These
results are surprising since naively one would only ex-
pect a peak at =
c
due to heating at the cyclotron
resonance. Interest in this phenomenon was heightened
when, using high mobility samples, both Mani et al. [2]
and Zudov et al. [3] observed that as the radiation inten-
sity is increased, the minimum resistance values approach
zero and give rise to new zero-resistance states. In this
Letter, we present calculations which reveal the origin
of the resistance oscillations, explain their period and
phase, hint at the manner in which zero-resistance states
may develop, and predict higher-order eects, likely due
to multi-photon processes, which set in at high intensity.
It is instructive to begin by exploring a crude treat-
ment through which a simple physical picture can be es-
tablished. The electronic states of 2D electrons without
disorder in a perpendicular magnetic eld, B, are the
Landau levels,
n
= n
c
, where
c
= eB/m c, the n
are nonnegative integers, and m is the eective mass.
(Here, and always, we set
= 1 and drop the constant
energy shift of
c
/2.) Each level has a degeneracy per
unit area of 1/2
2
where =
c/eB is the magnetic
length. In the presence of disorder, the Landau levels
are broadened. In correspondence with experiment, we c
V
n
= n c
+ eE
dc
x
n+2
n+1
n+3
n
+x
x
FIG. 1: Simple picture of radiation-induced disorder-assisted
current. Landau levels are tilted by the applied dc bias. Elec-
trons absorb photons and are excited by energy . Photo-
excited electrons are scattered by disorder and kicked to the
right or to the left by a distance ±x. If the nal density
of states to the left exceeds that to the right, dc current is
enhanced. If vice versa, dc current is diminished. Note that
electrons initially near the center of a Landau level (where the
initial density of states is greatest) will tend to ow uphill for
/
c integer + 1/4.
consider states occupied up to high Landau levels (the
lling factor is about 50 for the experiments of Ref. 2).
We suppose that the normalized eigenstates in the pres-
ence of disorder are (r), with eigenvalues . Now
we turn on the microwave radiation. When an electron
absorbs a photon, it is excited by an energy . In the
absence of disorder, conductivity is independent of the
distribution of electrons over Landau levels (Kohns the-
orem [4]) so photo-excited electrons can make no addi-
tional contribution to the dc current. In the presence of
disorder, these electrons can be scattered by impurities
as they are excited. We use a generalization of Fermis
golden rule to obtain a position-dependent rate. To sec-
ond order in the radiation, the rate at which an elec- 2
tron is scattered from initial state to nal position r
is w
(r) = 2 | (r)
|
2
(
)| |eEx| |
2
,
where
|eEx| is the matrix element of the electric
dipole operator of the radiation eld.
Initially, the
eigenstates are occupied with Fermi distribution func-
tion n
F
(
) about chemical potential
, and we insert
the factor [n
F
(
)
n
F
( )] so that nal states must
be unoccupied.
Then the additional current density
due to the radiation is J
x
(R) =
e dd
2
r [n
F
() n
F
( + )]
|
(r )
|
2
(

) w
(r) x. Here R =
1
2
(r + r ), r = r
r = (x, y). For the average over
disorder (denoted by an overbar throughout this paper),
we write this expression as
J
x
(R) =
2e dd
2
r [n
F
()
n
F
( + )]
×N(r, + )N(r , )M (r, r ) x
(1)
where
N(r,) = | (r)
|
2
(
) is the average lo-
cal density of states, which in high Landau levels obeys
N( + n
c
) =
N(). M(r,r ) > 0 is dened by extract-
ing these density of states factors, and is assumed to be
independent of the energies , + , and to be a func-
tion of
|r| only. To measure the conductivity in linear
response, a small dc electric eld, E
dc
, is applied in the
x-direction. This tilts the energy spectrum as depicted in
Fig. 1, and thus we assume that the only eect on Eq. (1)
is to make
N(r,) = N( eE
dc
x). J
x
vanishes to ze-
roth order in E
dc
by symmetry, and for linear response,
we expand to rst order in E
dc
, and divide by E
dc
to
nd the longitudinal conductivity,
xx
. We nd that the
radiation-induced change in the longitudinal conductiv-
ity is proportional to an integral of the partial derivative
((
N(r,+)N(r , ))/x)
R
. The density of states can
be roughly modelled by
N() = N
0
+
N
1
cos(2/
c
).
The nal integral over can now be done, and at least
for /
c
large compared to
N
0
/
N
1
, the result is xx
sin(2/
c
),
(2)
with a positive coecient. This form, which resembles
the derivative of the density of states (
N/)|
=
, arises
because the main contribution is from initial states near
the center of lled broadened Landau levels, which are
scattered to empty broadened levels, and the available
phase space is enhanced or diminished for x positive or
negative, depending on the energy change modulo
c
(see Fig. 1). It is clear from experiment that
xy
is nearly
100 times larger than
xx
and is not signicantly aected
by the radiation. Therefore, inverting the conductivity
tensor yields
xx

2
xy xx
, which has the period and
phase of the oscillations observed in experiment.
While the above treatment is highly oversimplied, it
indicates that disorder plays a crucial role and may be
all that is necessary to obtain the radiation-induced os-
cillations. This suggests that a diagrammatic (Kubo for-
mula) calculation of the conductivity, including radia-
tion and disorder but neglecting electron-electron inter-
actions, will be sucient to reproduce the eect. This
calculation is presented below.
In the Landau gauge and the rotating-wave approxima-
tion (we neglect both counter-rotating and guiding-center
terms in the coupling to radiation), the Hamiltonian is
H =
k,n
n
c
c

nk
c
nk
+
k,n;k ,n c

nk
c
n k V
n,k;n ,k + eE
2
k,n
n c

nk
c
n1,k
e
it
+ c

n1,k
c
nk
e
it
(3)
where n is the Landau level index, k is the y-component
of momentum, c
nk
is the electron annihilation operator,
V
n,k;n ,k are the matrix elements of the disorder po-
tential V
imp
(r), and E is the magnitude of the electric
eld component of the microwave radiation. Following
the calculation of Ando [5] for the zero-radiation case,
we shall include disorder within the self-consistent Born
approximation (SCBA) and assume V
imp
(r)V
imp
(r ) =
(2/m )(r
r ) where = 1/2 is the elastic scat-
tering rate in zero magnetic eld. This assumption of
-correlated disorder, while somewhat inappropriate for
the long-ranged impurity potentials associated with mod-
ulation doping, signicantly simplies the problem by
eliminating the momentum dependence of the self-energy.
Yet, as we shall see, it manages to capture the impor-
tant physics rather well. To all orders in the disorder
and radiation, the Greens functions are given by the di-
agrams in Fig. 2(a). Since the radiation terms connect
neighboring Landau levels, evaluating these diagrams for
the retarded or advanced Greens functions, G
R,A
nm
(t
1
, t
2
),
yields a matrix equation in Landau level indices n and
m. (The Greens functions are proportional to an iden-
tity matrix in the momentum label k, which is there-
fore dropped.) The presence of radiation renders this
an inherently non-equilibrium problem which requires
the approach of Kadano and Baym and Keldysh (see
Refs. [6, 7, 8] for details). This involves the lesser
Greens function, G
<
nm
(t
1
, t
2
), which is the only place
where the distribution of electrons enters, and which is
evaluated from the same set of diagrams via a slightly
more complex procedure. It is convenient to dene
¯
G
R,A,<
nm
(t,
T ) = e
int
1
G
R,A,<
nm
(t
1
, t
2
)e
imt
2
(4)
where t
t
1
t
2
,
T (t
1
+ t
2
)/2, and ¯
G
R,A,<
nm